Home Experiments Engineering Science Fair Projects Scientists & Inventors Engineering Fair Books Engineering Resources Science Jokes Warning!
 
 


Film Speed & Reciprocity




 


Experiments Home
Engineering
Film Speed





Engineering Science Fair Projects Home

  • Aviation
  • Airplanes
  • Rockets
  • Arrows & Projectiles
  • Ships & Boats
  • Cameras & Photography
  • Buildings
  • Bridges
  • Building Materials
  • Earthquake Building
  • Concrete
  • Wood
  • Cars
  • Machines
  • Sports Engineering
  • Water in Engineering
  • Books


  • Scientists and Inventors

    Scientists and Inventors




















    Scientists and Inventors

    Scientists and Inventors
    Film Speed & Reciprocity

    Film speed is the measure of a photographic film's sensitivity to light. Stock with lower sensitivity (lower ISO speed rating) requires a longer exposure and is thus called a slow film, while stock with higher sensitivity (higher ISO speed rating) can shoot the same scene with a shorter exposure and is called a fast film.

    In the first approximation the amount of light energy which reaches the film determines the effect on the emulsion, so that if the brightness of the light is multiplied by a factor and the exposure of the film decreased by the same factor so that the energy received is the same, the film will be exposed to the same density; this rule is called reciprocity, and the concept of a unique speed for an emulsion is possible because reciprocity holds. In practice this holds reasonably well for normal photographic films for the range of exposures usually used, say 1/1000 sec to 1 sec, but longer exposures, different for different films, are required outside these limits, a phenomenon known as reciprocity failure.

    Contents

    Film Speed
    Reciprocity & Reciprocity Failure

    Technical information

    ISO film speed scales

    The standard known as ISO 5800:1987 from the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) defines both a linear scale and a logarithmic scale for measuring film speed.

    In the ISO linear scale, which corresponds to the older ASA scale, doubling the speed of a film (that is, halving the amount of light that is necessary to expose the film) implies doubling the numeric value that designates the film speed. In the ISO logarithmic scale, which corresponds to the older DIN scale, doubling the speed of a film implies adding 3° to the numeric value that designates the film speed. For example, a film rated ISO 200/24° is twice as sensitive as a film rated ISO 100/21°.

    Commonly, the logarithmic (DIN) component is omitted from film speed ratings, and only the linear component is given (e.g. "ISO 100"). In such cases, the quoted "ISO" rating is in effect synonymous with the older ASA standard.

    GOST (Russian: ГОСТ) is a pre-1987 linear standard used in the former Eastern Bloc. It was almost, but not quite identical to the ASA standard. After 1987 the GOST scale was aligned to the ISO scale. GOST markings are only found on pre-1987 photographic equipment (film, cameras, lightmeters, etc.) of Eastern Bloc manufacture.

    The most common ISO film ratings are 25/15°, 50/18°, 100/21°, 200/24°, 400/27°, 800/30°, 1600/33°, and 3200/36°. Consumer films are generally rated between 100/21° and 800/30°, inclusive.

    A film speed is converted from the linear scale to the logarithmic scale by this formula (plus rounding to the nearest integer):

    \mbox{log scale speed} = 3\,\log_2\left(\frac{128}{100} \,\mbox{linear speed}\right) \!

    Conversion from the logarithmic scale to the linear scale is analogous, except that results must be rounded to the conventional values of the linear scale listed in the table below.

    \mbox{linear speed} = \frac{100}{128}\,2^{\left({\frac{1}{3}\mbox{log scale speed}}\right)} \!

    The following table shows the correspondence between these scales:

    ISO linear scale
    (old ASA scale)
    ISO log scale
    (old DIN scale)
    GOST
    (Soviet pre-1987)
    Example of film stock
    with this nominal speed
    6 original Kodachrome
    8 10°
    10 11° Kodachrome 8 mm film
    12 12° 11 Gevacolor 8 mm reversal film
    16 13° 11 Agfacolor 8 mm reversal film
    20 14° 16
    25 15° 22 old Agfacolor, Kodachrome 25
    32 16° 22 Kodak Panatomic-X
    40 17° 32 Kodachrome 40 (movie)
    50 18° 45 Fuji RVP (Velvia)
    64 19° 45 Kodachrome 64, Ektachrome-X
    80 20° 65 Ilford Commercial Ortho
    100 21° 90 Kodacolor Gold, Kodak T-Max (TMX)
    125 22° 90 Ilford FP4, Kodak Plus-X Pan
    160 23° 130 Fuji NPS, Kodak High-Speed Ektachrome
    200 24° 180 Fujicolor Superia 200
    250 25° 180
    320 26° 250 Kodak Tri-X Pan Professional (TXP)
    400 27° 350 Kodak T-Max (TMY), Tri-X 400, Ilford HP5
    500 28° 350
    640 29° 560 Polaroid 600
    800 30° 700 Fuji NPZ
    1000 31° 700 Ilford Delta 3200 (see text below)
    1250 32°
    1600 33° 1400–1440 Fujicolor 1600
    2000 34°
    2500 35°
    3200 36° 2800–2880 old Konica 3200
    4000 37°
    5000 38°
    6400 39°

    Determining film speed

    Film speed is found by referencing the Hurter–Driffield curve, or D–logE curve, for the film. This is a plot of optical density vs. log of exposure (lux-s). There are typically five regions in the curve: the base + fog, the toe, the linear region, the shoulder, and the overexposed region. Following the curve to the point where density exceeds the base + fog by 0.1, find the corresponding exposure. Dividing 0.8 by that exposure yields the linear ISO speed rating.

    Applying film speed

    Film speed is used in the exposure equation to find the appropriate exposure parameters. Four variables are available to the photographer to obtain the desired effect: lighting, film speed, f-number (aperture size), and shutter speed (exposure time). The equation may be expressed as ratios, or, by taking the logarithm (base 2) of both sides, by addition, using the APEX system, in which every increment of 1 is a doubling of exposure, known as a "stop". The f-number is proportional to the ratio between the lens focal length and aperture diameter, which is proportional to the square root of the aperture area. Thus, a lens set to f/1.4 allows twice as much light to strike the focal plane as a lens set to f/2. Therefore, each f-number factor of the square root of two (approximately 1.4) is also a stop, so lenses are typically marked in that progression: f/1.4, 2, 2.8, 4, 5.6, 8, 11, 16, 22, 32, etc.

    Exposure index

    Exposure index, or EI, refers to speed rating assigned to a particular film and shooting situation, and used in the exposure meter or equation, to compensate for equipment calibration inaccuracies or process variables, or to achieve certain effects. Exposure index may or may not be the same as manufacturer's film speed rating for that particular film.

    The exposure index is sometimes called the speed setting, as opposed to the speed rating.

    For example, a photographer may choose to rate a 400 ISO speed film at 800 and then use push processing in order to get printable negatives from low-light conditions. In this case it is said that film has been shot at EI 800.

    Another example of a situation when exposure index would differ from film manufacturer's rating is when a camera shutter is known to be miscalibrated and consistently overexposes or underexposes the film; similarly, a light meter can be known to understate or overstate lighting conditions. In such cases one could adjust EI rating accordingly in order to compensate for these effects and consistently produce correctly exposed negatives.

    Film grain

    Main article: Film grain
    Grainy high speed B/W film negative
    Grainy high speed B/W film negative

    Film speed is roughly related to granularity, the size of the grains of silver halide in the emulsion, since larger grains give film a greater sensitivity to light. Fine-grain stock, such as portrait film or those used for the intermediate stages of copying original camera negatives, is "slow", meaning that the amount of light used to expose it must be high or the shutter must be open longer. Fast films, used for shooting in poor light or for shooting fast motion, produce a grainier image. Each grain of silver halide develops in an all-or-nothing way into dark silver or nothing. Thus, each grain is a threshold detector; in aggregate, their effect can be thought of as a noisy nonlinear analog light detector.

    Kodak has defined a "Print Grain Index" (PGI) to characterize film grain (color negative films only), based on perceptual just noticeable difference of graininess in prints. They also define "granularity", a measurement of grain using an RMS measurement of density fluctuations in uniformly-exposed film, measured with a microdensitometer with 48 micrometre aperture.[1] Granularity varies with exposure — underexposed film looks grainier than overexposed film.

    Improvements in film

    In the early 1980s, there were some radical improvements in film stock. It became possible to shoot color film in very low light and produce a fine-grained image with a good range of midtones.

    Use of grain

    In advertising, music videos, and some drama, mismatches of grain, color cast, and so forth between shots are often deliberate and added in post-production.

    Altering film speed

    Certain high-speed black-and-white films, such as Ilford Delta 3200 and Kodak T-Max P3200 (TMZ), are marketed with higher speeds on the box than their true ISO speed (determined using the ISO testing methodology). For example, the Ilford product is actually an ISO 1000 film, according to its data sheet. The manufacturers are careful not to refer to the 3200 number as an ISO speed on the packaging. These films can be successfully exposed at EI 3200 (or any of several other speeds) through the use of push processing. The most sensitive sensor common in commercial photography may be the Silicon Intensified Target vidicon, at ASA 200,000, used in TV cameras.

    Digital camera ISO speed and exposure index

    For digital photo cameras ("digital still cameras"), the ISO standard 12232:2006[2] specifies several definitions of the speed rating depending on the sensor sensitivity, the sensor noise, and the appearance of the resulting image. The digital ISO speed ratings are related to the conventional film-speed ratings in how a standard 18 percent reflective surface would appear in an image under given lighting conditions.

    ISO speed ratings of a digital camera are based on the properties of the sensor and the image processing done in the camera, and are expressed in terms of the luminous exposure H (in lux seconds) arriving at the sensor. For a typical camera lens with an effective focal length f that is much smaller than the distance between the camera and the photographed scene, H is given by

    H = \frac{q L t}{N^2},

    where L is the luminance of the scene (in candela per m², t is the exposure time (in seconds), N is the aperture f-number, and

    q = \frac{\pi}{4} T\, v(\theta)\, \cos^4\theta

    is a prefactor depending on the transmittance T of the lens, the vignetting factor v(θ), and the angle θ relative to the axis of the lens. A typical value is q = 0.65, based on θ=10°, T=0.9, and v=0.98.

    The saturation-based speed is defined as

    S_{\mathrm{sat}} = \frac{78}{H_{\mathrm{sat}}},

    where Hsat is the maximum possible exposure that does not lead to a clipped or bloomed camera output. Typically, the lower limit of the saturation speed is determined by the sensor itself, but with the gain of the amplifier between the sensor and the A/D-converter, the saturation speed can be increased. The factor 78 is chosen such that exposure settings based on a standard light meter and an 18-percent reflective surface will result in an image with a grey level of 18%/√2 = 12.7% of saturation. The factor √2 indicates that there is half a stop of headroom to deal with specular reflections that would appear brighter than a 100% reflecting white surface.

    The noise-based speed is defined as the exposure that will lead to a given signal-to-noise ratio on individual pixels. Two ratios are used, the 40:1 ("excellent image quality") and the 10:1 ("acceptable image quality") ratio. These ratios have been subjectively determined based on a resolution of 70 pixels per cm (180 DPI) when viewed at 25 cm (10 inch) distance. The signal-to-noise ratio is defined as the standard deviation of a weighted average of the luminance (overall brightness) and color of individual pixels. The noise-based speed is mostly determined by the properties of the sensor and somewhat affected by the noise in the electronic gain and AD converter.

    In addition to the above speed ratings, the standard also defines the standard output sensitivity (SOS), how the exposure is related to the digital pixel values in the output image. It is defined as

    S_{\mathrm{sos}} = \frac{10}{H_{\mathrm{sos}}},

    where Hsos is the exposure that will lead to values of 118 in 8-bit pixels, which is 18 percent of the saturation value in images encoded as sRGB or with gamma=2.2.

    The standard specifies how speed ratings should be reported by the camera. If the noise-based speed (40:1) is higher than the saturation-based speed, the noise-based speed should be reported, rounded downwards to a standard value (e.g. 200, 250, 320, or 400). The rationale is that exposure according to the lower saturation-based speed would not result in a visibly better image. In addition, an exposure latitude can be specified, ranging from the saturation-based speed to the 10:1 noise-based speed. If the noise-based speed (40:1) is lower than the saturation-based speed, or undefined because of high noise, the saturation-based speed is specified, rounded upwards to a standard value, because using the noise-based speed would lead to overexposed images. The camera may also report the SOS-based speed (explicitly as being an SOS speed), rounded to the nearest standard speed rating.

    For example, a camera sensor may have the following properties: S40:1 = 107, S10:1 = 1688, and Ssat = 49. According to the standard, the camera should report its sensitivity as

    ISO 100 (daylight)
    ISO speed latitude 50–1600
    ISO 100 (SOS, daylight).

    The SOS rating could be user-controlled. For a different camera with a noisier sensor, the properties might be S40:1 = 40, S10:1 = 800, and Ssat = 200. In this case, the camera should report

    ISO 200 (daylight),

    as well as an user-adjustable SOS value. In all cases, the camera should indicate for the white balance setting for which the speed rating applies, such as daylight or tungsten (incandescent light).

    Despite these detailed standard definitions, cameras typically do not clearly indicate whether the user "ISO" setting refers to the noise-based speed, saturation-based speed, or the specified output sensitivity, or even some made-up number for marketing purposes.

    As should be clear from the above, a greater SOS setting for a given sensor comes with some loss of image quality, just like with analog film. However, this loss is visible as image noise rather than grain. The best digital cameras as of 2008 exhibit no perceptible noise at ISO 200 sensitivity, and some produce usable results up to ISO 25,600.

    References

    • Leslie Stroebel, John Compton, Ira Current, and Richard Zakia. Basic Photographic Materials and Processes, second edition. Boston: Focal Press, 2000. ISBN 0-240-80405-8.

    See also

    External links

    Reciprocity & Reciprocity Failure

    In photography and holography, reciprocity refers to the inverse relationship between the intensity and duration of light that determines exposure of light-sensitive material. Within a normal exposure range for film stock, for example, the reciprocity law states that exposure = intensity × time. Therefore, the same exposure can result from reducing duration and increasing light intensity, and vice versa. Total exposure of the film or sensor, the product of focal-plane illuminance times exposure time, is measured in lux seconds.

    The reciprocal relationship is assumed in most sensitometry, for example when measuring a Hurter and Driffield curve for a photographic emulsion.

    Photography

    In photography reciprocity refers to the relationship whereby the total light energy, proportional to the product of the light intensity and exposure time (controlled by aperture and shutter speed), determines the effective exposure; an increase of brightness by a certain factor being equivalent to a decrease of exposure time by the same factor. For most photographic materials reciprocity is valid with good accuracy over a range of values of exposure duration, but becomes increasingly inaccurate as we depart from this range: reciprocity failure. As the light level decreases out of the reciprocity range, the increase in duration required to produce an exposure becomes higher than the formula states; for instance, at half of the light required for a normal exposure, the duration must be more than doubled for the same result. Multipliers used to correct for this effect are called reciprocity factors (see model below).

    In other words there is under normal circumstances an inverse linear relationship between aperture area and shutter speed, with a wider aperture requiring a faster shutter speed for the same exposure. (Or we can speak of direct proportionality between aperture area and the reciprocal of shutter speed; hence reciprocity.) For example, an exposure value of 10 may be achieved with an aperture of f/2.8 and a shutter speed of 1/125 s. The same exposure is achieved by doubling the aperture area to f/2 and halving the shutter speed to 1/250 s or by halving the aperture area to f/4.0 and doubling the shutter speed to 1/60 s.

    However, during very long exposures, film responds less than usual. Light can be considered to be a stream of discrete photons, and a light-sensitive emulsion is composed of discrete light-sensitive grains, usually silver halide crystals. Each grain must absorb a certain number of photons in order for the light-driven reaction to occur and the latent image to form. In particular, if the surface of the silver halide crystal has a cluster of approximately four or more reduced silver atoms, resulting from absorption of a sufficient number of photons (usually a few dozen photons are required), it is rendered developable. At low light levels, i.e. few photons per unit time, photons impinge upon each grain relatively infrequently; if the four photons required arrive over a long enough interval, the partial change due to the first one or two are not stable enough to survive before enough photons arrive to make a permanent latent image center.

    This breakdown in the linear relationship between aperture and shutter speed is known as reciprocity failure. Each different film "emulsion" has a different response to long exposure. Some films are very susceptible to reciprocity failure, and others much less so. Some films that are very light sensitive at normal illumination levels and normal exposure times lose much of their sensitivity at long exposure times, becoming effectively "slow" films for long exposures. Conversely some films that are "slow" under normal exposure duration retain their light sensitivity better at long exposures. Compared at very long exposure times, Kodak's T-Max 100 speed film is faster than nominally 4 times faster Tri-X 400. Most film manufacturers publish reciprocity corrections.

    For example, for a given film, if a light meter indicates a required EV of 5 and the photographer sets the aperture to f/11, then ordinarily a 4 second exposure would be required; a reciprocity correction factor of 1.5 would require the exposure to be extended to 6 seconds for the same result. Reciprocity failure generally becomes significant at exposures of longer than about 1 sec and below about 1 ms for film, and above 30 sec for paper.

    Reciprocity effects can also occur within the tonal range of a photographic scene when at the limit of exposure, resulting in burnt highlights while losing detail in the shadows. The composition of the film stock used, and in particular the relative amounts of silver bromide, silver chloride and silver iodide, can adjust this tonal response for the desired effect.

    Reciprocity also breaks down at extremely high levels of illumination with very short exposures. This is concern for scientific and technical photography, but rarely to general photographers, as exposures significantly shorter than a millisecond are only required for subjects such as explosions and particle physics experiments, or when taking high-speed motion pictures with very high shutter speeds (1/10,000 sec or less).

    Astrophotography

    Reciprocity failure is an important effect in the field of film-based astrophotography. Deep-sky objects such as galaxies and nebulae are often so faint that they are not visible to the un-aided eye. To make matters worse, many objects' spectra do not line up with the film emulsion's sensitivity curves. Many of these targets are small and require long focal lengths, which can push the focal ratio far above f/5. Combined, these parameters make these targets extremely difficult to capture with film; exposures from 30 minutes to well over an hour are typical. As a typical example, capturing an image of the Andromeda Galaxy at f/4 will take about 30 minutes; to get the same density at f/8 would require an exposure of about 200 minutes. When a telescope is tracking an object, every minute is difficult; therefore, reciprocity failure is one of the biggest motivations for astronomers to switch to digital imaging.

    Holography

    A similar problem exists in holography. The total energy required when exposing holographic film using a continuous wave laser (i.e. for several seconds) is significantly less than the total energy required when exposing holographic film using a pulsed laser (i.e. around 20–40 nanoseconds) due to a reciprocity failure. It can also be caused by very long or very short exposures with a continuous wave laser. To try to offset the reduced brightness of the film due to reciprocity failure, a method called latensification can be used. This is usually done directly after the holographic exposure and using an incoherent light source (such as a 25-40W light bulb). Exposing the holographic film to the light for a few seconds can increase the brightness of the hologram by an order of magnitude.

    References

    Links


    This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from Wikipedia Encyclopedia article "Film Speed"

    Scientists and Inventors    Scientists and Inventors    Scientists and Inventors   

    My Dog Kelly

    Site Map ♣ About Us ♣ Patent-Invent ♣ Free Theses, Dissertations & Patents

    Comments and inquiries could be addressed to:
    webmaster@julianTrubin.com


    Last updated: January 2008
    Copyright © 2003-2008 Julian Rubin